The purple pill tops the list of the most expensive drugs for government health programs in 2013. No, your first reaction to blame the government is wrong — the drug is prescribed by health care providers — and, the government is prevented by law from negotiating drug prices. Why is this a problem? –there was a perfectly fine OTC generic substitute available in 2013 at only 6% of the cost.
WHAT??? Prescribers wrote prescriptions for a drug that could have been substituted by an equivalent drug and saved 94%. OK, at the margins of the argument, at the fringes of reality, at the level it makes no clinical difference, big pharma says it might not be a perfect substitute. A good example where the “perfect” is the enemy of the very good.
But, how could prescribers and patients have the wool pulled over their eyes? — fantastic marketing. And, by the way, if you take this drug, send me your name, address, social security number, and bank account number, I have a nice bridge to sell you.
The magnitude of the problem became crystal clear when CMS published prescription data. The following data is widely reported from CMS as the spending on drugs through Medicare’s Part D prescription-drug program in 2013:
|Rank||Brand Name||Generic Name||Number of Claims||Cost in Billions|
Omeprazole is a very good substitute for Nexium for heartburn and reflux. Despite the cloud of industry generated studies many pharmacists say the two drugs have equal effects. As the table above shows omeprazole was prescribed 4 times as often as Nexium but the providers who chose Nexium created a vastly larger and unnecessary cost. Why Nexium is even be on the Medicare Part-D formulary is a mystery. Who pays the bill? — taxpayers, of course, and the patients who paid a co-pay higher than the full cost of an equivalent.
In 2015 Nexium became an over the counter drug (OTC) and just as you might suspect it now costs about the same as OTC omeprazole — about $32 for 56 pills (at Costco) rather than $300.
Where is the oversight? Where is the cost control? Why is US healthcare so expensive? Need more examples? Just look at the other medications on the list.